top of page

Great Employees Don't Automatically Become Great Managers

Writer: Elvira Tapler
Elvira Tapler
Oct 18
3 min read

Why preparing emerging leaders matters more than ever.


Who will lead your organization next -- and are they being prepared for it? We often recognize leadership potential in our strongest employees. They're trusted problem-solvers, reliable performers, and the people others naturally turn to for guidance.


But here's the challenge: Being great at your job doesn't automatically prepare you to lead others.


The skills that earn someone a promotion aren't necessarily the skills that help them succeed as a people leader. In a June 2025 SHRM discussion of management development, leadership researcher and author Joseph Grenny reported that nearly two-thirds of new managers admitted leadership was harder than they expected.


The Shift from Doing to Leading

The Center for Creative Leadership (CCL) describes the move from individual contributor to manager as a significant identity shift, requiring people to move beyond relying primarily on their own expertise and learn to achieve results through others. CCL’s research underscores the preparation gap: almost 60% of first-time managers reported receiving no training when they transitioned into their first leadership role, while 26% said they did not feel ready to lead others.


When Managers Struggle, Teams Feel It

Early training helps people managers build the foundational skills that become essential once they are responsible for others, such as communicating expectations, giving feedback, coaching performance, handling conflict, delegating effectively, exercising judgment, and shifting from “doing” to leading.


This investment matters beyond the individual leader. An unprepared manager does not struggle in isolation: the effects can spread across an entire team and may show up in micromanagement, weak delegation, avoiding performance conversations, poorly managed conflict, inconsistent accountability, manager stress, employee disengagement, and turnover. Gallup's research finds that managers account for approximately 70% of the variance in team-level employee engagement, which means the manager’s skills largely influence employees' workplace experience.


One of the critical skills for an emerging leader, for example, is knowing how to address poor performance or problematic behaviors early. SHRM research recently identified that fewer than half of managers effectively address employee underperformance or areas needing improvement. The typical outcomes are inconsistent accountability, lingering performance problems, employee relations issues, and greater reliance on HR involvement once those unresolved situations escalate.


Preparing Leaders Before They Need to Lead

The impact of a team leader is too important to be left to trial and error. According to SHRM, while 64% of HR professionals report that internal promotion is their primary method of filling management positions, only 30% of organizations have a formal onboarding process for internally promoted managers. This gap underscores the importance of preparing employees for leadership before they're expected to navigate its challenges.


Preparing people to lead doesn't happen by chance. It takes intention, opportunities to practice, and the right support.


From Insight to Impact: Questions to Consider

  • Are we recognizing leadership potential—or assuming that strong individual performance translates into strong leadership?

  • How are we preparing employees for the shift from doing the work to leading others?

  • What might the cost be to our teams, our culture, and our organization when managers are expected to learn through trial and error?


The takeaway: Leadership potential is a starting point. Intentional development is what helps turn that potential into effective leadership.


Turning Leadership Potential into Leadership Success

At Integra HR, we believe that developing strong people leaders begins before challenges arise. Our new Management Readiness Program helps emerging and current managers build practical skills in communication, performance management, conflict resolution, and organizing work.


Through five interactive virtual sessions, participants gain tools, confidence, and opportunities to practice the everyday responsibilities of leading others.


Interested in preparing your next generation of leaders? 


Connect with our  Performance Consultants today to learn more about Integra's Management Readiness Program. 



​

Integra HR, LLC 

15 2nd Avenue • Rensselaer, NY 12144

33 Smith Street • Niantic, CT 06357

1-518-917-3300

  • Facebook
  • Grey LinkedIn Icon
  • YouTube

Disclaimer:  Integra will not be practicing any type of law, providing legal counsel or performing any other form of legal services.  Like other HR consulting firms, we will refer the client to legal counsel for those types of services. 

 

© 2026 Integra HR, LLC. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy

Website designed by Christy Toms

bottom of page